| Year | Regular Season | Playoffs |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 |  Pirates | Pirates |
| 2022 |  White Sox | White Sox |
| 2021 | White Sox | Pirates |
| 2019 | White Sox |  Yankees |
| 2018 | Pirates | |
| 2017 | White Sox | |
| 2016 | Pirates | |
| 2015 | White Sox | |
| 2014 |  Reds | |
| 2013 | White Sox | |
| 2012 | White Sox | |
| 2011 | White Sox | |
| 2010 |  Marlins | |
| 2009 | Yankees | |
| 2008 | ||
| 2007 | ||
| 2006 | ||
| 2005 | ||
| 2004 |